Back to A methodological review of U.S. indicator projects

a. Sustainable Seattle: A National Model Indicators for Sustainable Community - Seattle, Washington



The Seattle project was organized by Sustainable Seattle, a volunteer organization made up of individuals from city and county government, environment, business and labor, religious, and social activism communities in Seattle and the surrounding Puget Sound region. Seattle's project progress through five critical stages.3 At an initial meeting of 16 people, the Global Tomorrow Coalition developed a mission statement and a definition of sustainability. Next, they appointed a group of 25 trustees to assist in the definition of the project and serve as advisors during the identification of the indicators and the research. The trustees were community leaders representing all sectors of the community. As community leaders they also helped to insure that the indicator project would be used effectively in other projects and research. Third, a "task team" was then put together to generate the first 150 draft indicators.

The fourth step involved bringing together approximately 250 leaders and activists from business, government, academia, nonprofit organizations, and the general public. The first panel was held in December of 1992 and was meant to give direction and promote community ownership of the project. The panel reviewed and amended the indicator list. Then four more civic panels and additional subcommittee meetings were held over the next five months. They generated 99 indicators, grouped into ten topic areas.

In the last stage, the task team selected 40 of the 99 indicators for research and publication. The Indicators for Sustainable Community document was then sent to government agencies, community organizations, schools, businesses, and the general public for review.

This project has served as a template for many other indicator projects. It was comprehensive, included intense public involvement, and continued into the future with objectives and revisions. It had less direct impact on local government than other projects due to its "bottom-up" process, but with its diverse and active membership, this project has made a considerable impact on Seattleís (and many other placesí) path towards sustainability.

In Indicators of Sustainable Community, Sustainable Seattle determined five main categories under which most aspects of sustainability fit: Environment, Population and Resources, Economy, Youth and Education, and Health and Community. Table 1 summarizes these subject areas and their associated indicators and sources of data.

Table 1: Seattle's Indicators and Data Sources 4
Category: Source of Data:
Environment
Specific Species Health: State Department of Fisheries and Wildlife statistics
Specific Area/Ecosystem Health: EPA Clean Water Act
Special Research Programs (i.e. Wetlands Management Research Program)
Biodiversity: Puget Sound Wetlands and Stormwater Research Program
Soil Erosion: USGS and Department of Ecology
Air Quality: EPA Pollution Standards Index (PSI)
Air Pollution Control Agency
Pedestrian-Friendly Streets: Engineering Department counted % of pedestrian-friendly streets
Open Space in Urban Villages: City of Seattle Planning Department
Impervious Surfaces: Engineering Department's Drainage and Wastewater Utility
Population and Resources
Population: Census data-Forecasting Division / Office of Financial Management
Residential Water Consumption: Water Department
Solid Waste Generated and Recycled: Solid Waste Division
Pollution Prevention and Renewable Resource Use: EPA Toxic Release Inventory
Use of Recycled products from the American Forest and Paper Association
Farm Acreage: U.S. Census of Agriculture
National Agriculture Statistics Service Bulletin
Vehicle Miles Traveled and Fuel Consumption: Department of Transportation
Revenue for motor fuel taxes
Renewable and Nonrenewable Energy Use: State Department of Transportation (gas)
State Energy Office; Seattle City Light; Puget Power
Washington Natural Gas
Air Pollution Control Agency
Economy
Employment Concentration: Financial Advisors; Employment at Top Ten Companies in area
Economic Development Council; Business Journal
Real Unemployment: U.S. Department of Labor-Bureau of Labor Statistics
Distribution of Personal Income: U.S. Census
Health Care Expenditures: (does not reflect quality of care, % with access, or amount spent caring for illness instead of
preventing it/promoting health)
Office of Financial Management
Work Required for Basic Needs: U.S. Census-County Business patterns-U.S. Dept. of Commerce (to determine hourly wage)
U.S. Dept of Housing and Urban Development (which determines "Need Standard" annually)
Housing Affordability Ratio: County Planning and Community Development Division
Children Living in Poverty: U.S. Census
Emergency Room Use for Non-Emergency Purposes: Hospitals
State Department of Health
Community Capital: Consumer Price Index (loan potential)
Youth and Education
Adult Literacy: State Office of Adult Literacy
U.S. Census
"Adult Literacy in Washington" study
High School Graduation: Public School District Annual Reports
Ethnic Diversity of Teachers: Public School District Annual Reports
Arts Instruction: No data
Volunteer Involvement in Schools: # volunteers, PTSA members vs. students
Juvenile Crime: Police
Criminal Justice Division of the county's Office of the Prosecuting Attorney
Youth Involvement in Community Service: YMCA and such
Health and Community
Equity and Justice: Study by Governor's Juvenile Justice Advisory Committee and the Disproportionality Working Group
Low Birthweight Infants: Department of Public Health-birth certificates
Asthma Hospitalization Rate for Children: Comprehensive Hospital Abstract Reporting System-State Department of Health
Voter Participation: County Clerk-odd year election info-primaries
Library and Community Center Use: Books checked out/capita
Public Library system, American Library Directory, State Library Statistical Bulletin
Annual Visits/ year @ Community Centers (list from State Department of Parks and
Recreation)
Public Participation in the Arts: NEA; Arts Commission
Cultural Resources Division
Gardening: Survey
Neighborliness in King County: Survey
Perceived Quality of Life: Survey